A team of professionals replacing a commercial roof.

A well-maintained roof is crucial for the longevity and functionality of any commercial property. When it comes to commercial roof replacement, you may find yourself contemplating whether to tackle the project yourself or seek professional help. In this blog post, we will examine the pros and cons of both approaches to help you make an informed decision.

DIY Commercial Roof Replacement

Pros of DIY

  1. Cost-saving: One of the primary reasons some business owners consider a DIY commercial roof replacement is the potential cost savings. By avoiding professional labor costs, you can significantly reduce your expenses.
  2. Flexibility: When you choose to replace your commercial roof yourself, you have the freedom to work at your own pace and on your schedule. This flexibility allows you to balance the project with your other business commitments.
  3. Enhanced control: Undertaking the roof replacement yourself enables you to have complete control over every aspect of the job. From selecting materials to overseeing the installation process, you can ensure that your commercial roof meets your specific requirements.

Cons of DIY

  1. Lack of expertise: Commercial roof replacement is a complex task that requires specialized knowledge and experience. Without the necessary expertise, you may end up making mistakes that could compromise the integrity of your commercial roof in the long run.
  2. Safety concerns: Working at heights without proper training and equipment can be extremely dangerous. A commercial roof installation project involves potential hazards, such as falls and accidents caused by improper handling of materials. It’s essential to prioritize safety and consider whether you possess the necessary skills and safety protocols to avoid accidents.
  3. Time-consuming: Undertaking a DIY commercial roof replacement project can often take longer than anticipated. Learning curves, unexpected challenges, and trial-and-error can significantly prolong the completion timeline. This extended project duration may affect your business operations and result in unnecessary delays.

Professional Commercial Roof Replacement

Advantages of Hiring Professionals

  1. Expertise and experience: When you hire professionals for commercial roof replacement, you benefit from their expertise and experience. Trained and certified roofing professionals possess the necessary skills to handle complex roof installations and ensure quality workmanship. They are well-versed in various commercial roofing systems and can guide you in selecting the most suitable materials for your specific needs.
  2. Time-saving: Professionals understand the importance of completing the project efficiently to minimize disruption to your business operations. Their experience allows them to execute the installation process swiftly while maintaining high standards. By hiring professionals, you can save valuable time and focus on other aspects of running your business.
  3. Insurance coverage: Professional roofing contractors typically carry liability insurance. This coverage protects you against any damages or accidents that may occur during the roof replacement project. It provides peace of mind, knowing that you are not financially responsible for any unfortunate incidents that may happen on your property.

Potential drawbacks of Professional Roof Replacement

  1. Cost: Hiring professionals for commercial roof replacement generally involves a higher upfront cost compared to a DIY approach. However, it is essential to consider the long-term benefits and potential cost savings. By relying on professionals, you can avoid costly mistakes, ensure quality workmanship, and secure durable roofing materials that will extend the lifespan of your commercial roof.
  2. Dependency: When you hire professionals for commercial roof replacement, you are more reliant on their expertise and decisions regarding the project. You may have limited control over the timeline and specific details, as you are relying on their professional judgment. It is crucial to establish clear communication and expectations with the roofing contractor.

Choosing the Right Option: Factors to Consider

In determining whether to opt for a DIY commercial roof replacement or seek professional help, there are several factors you need to consider:

  1. Roof complexity: The complexity of the project plays a significant role in deciding between a DIY approach and professional assistance. If your commercial roof system is intricate, with multiple layers and unique design elements, it may be best to rely on experienced professionals who can handle the complexity with precision.
  2. Budget: A crucial aspect to evaluate is your budget. While DIY projects may initially seem cheaper, consider the long-term investment. Professional roof replacement ensures quality workmanship, durable commercial roof materials, and potential cost savings down the line. Assess your financial capabilities and weigh the short-term cost against the long-term benefits.
  3. Time constraints: The urgency of your commercial roof replacement can influence whether you should hire professionals or undertake the project yourself. If time is of the essence, professionals can expedite the process to minimize disruptions, allowing you to resume normal business activities quickly.
  4. Safety concerns: Safety should always be a top priority, particularly when it comes to complex projects like roof replacement. If you lack the proper safety training and equipment, it may be wiser to hire experienced professionals who possess the knowledge and protocols to handle potential risks.


Making the choice between a DIY commercial roof replacement and seeking professional help can be challenging. By assessing the complexity of your roof, budget constraints, time availability, and safety concerns, you can make an informed decision that aligns with your specific requirements. Remember, even if you choose to embark on a DIY project, it is always wise to consult professionals for advice and guidance to ensure project success and safety.

At J.R. Swigart Roofing, we offer comprehensive commercial roofing services, including installation, replacement, repair, and maintenance. Our team of experienced professionals is here to guide you through the decision-making process and provide reliable solutions tailored to your commercial roofing needs. Contact us today to discuss your commercial roofing project!


Recommended Posts